Sunday, September 20, 2009

UH OH....


Well, the video does not include the discussion as promised by Rick (the CNN presenter), so I will fill in with my own thoughts.

The reason why this video grabbed public attention, was simply because we all have this common perception of an ideal President, and Barack Obama defied that perception in less than 10 seconds. Some people felt it was refreshing that finally a President has a backbone, but some might feel Obama’s comment was sloppy and improper coming from a leader. I stand with the latter group. Let us decipher exactly our cognitive processors that enabled us to be stunned by Obama’s insult.

In society we all have shared social understandings, and embedded in us is a cognitive schemata, or mental framework of how Presidents or Leaders should behave. This is known as Person Prototypes, idealized representations of certain kind of people. We might even subconsciously possess templates for how a President should speak, with scripts excluding the word “jackass” from any politician’s vocabulary. We form this knowledge due to past experiences of great leaders and how they conducted themselves.

However, such prototypes often generalize, and we may end up forming stereotyped views of Obama, criticizing him for lacking an image we have created. We also fail to realize that in the past, media excess was not as advanced as compared to modern times, and as such perhaps inappropriate behavior by past leaders were not publicized. Currently, anything can be recorded, and in a push of a button distributed to the whole world. That is the power of our media now. Obama had used the media to his advantage during campaigns, but its efficiency can backfire as seen in this video example.

Thank goodness though, that it was Obama, a black man, who aimed his insult at another black person. I can imagine if a white President had condemned Kayne, there would be media uproar on concerns regarding racism. Whether or not race is an issue, people tend to judge and interpret information based on appearances.

Another explanation why Obama’s criticism of Kayne sparked our interest was because of emotional proximity. We find ourselves identifying with celebrities or entertainers like Kayne more even if we have absolutely nada association with them. There are always so many citizens involved in debate over celebrity matters as they would normally contribute insight on country reforms.

My basis for thinking Obama’s comment was unprofessional and inappropriate, is because Presidents are role models and they have a lot of influence over people. After his remark, impressionable children might think insulting others is okay now. While we are all free to express our opinions, I think that damaging comments should still be discouraged. Obama thought this way as well, which explains why he requested for this clip to be cut (unfortunately his demand was ignored).

Watching this video, we must remember to apply mindful processing in evaluating information we get. We must be aware of how our perceptions might influence our sense of things and people. Obama probably meant his 'insult' as a casual response in an informal context and we should be wary not to jump to conclusions.

Here is a seperate clip showing how perception shapes our view of the world around us, and how that view might not be what it seems.

32 comments:

  1. Hi! Firstly, I realise you have a tendency of choosing topics regarding leaders. (Previously regarding the mayor and now the President... just something I noticed) Regarding the President's comment on Kanye being a "jackass", I think we should not have such strong judgements on him. You can clearly tell from his body language (that he was relax) and his tone (casual) that he was merely joking about this issue and what he said shouldn't have been taken so seriously. Maybe he should have taken note of what he said being a public figure, as his every action may influence some others. However, why should we be so quick to judge? I mean, he was merely passing a casual remark, so "cut the president some slack", he is also human and will have opinions of his own. Now we know who's side the President's on. As for Mr President, maybe next time, he should take note of the intensity of the word he use. "Jackass" may be too strong a word for most people to handle coming out from a President's mouth.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeos R o(^-^)
    ( )o
    As president of the United States, I think he should not have said the word "jackass". However, as obama, the common man, why not...afterall kanye West truely deserved to be branded that title! Kanye West had added that Beyonce's mv was better than taylor swift's--that MTV favored whites to blacks...I felt that he was trying to create disharmony between the two races and Obama's comment was indeed the best he had ever given since he became President.

    But if you watch the video carefully, you will notice that Obama immediately regretted his comment on Kanye. In fact, I thought he looked a little worried after that word came bluttering out of his mouth don't you think?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like your video! Interesting!
    It really depicts what perception is all about.
    The idea of pretty girls having beautiful voices but the ugly girl is the one who had it. I guess first impression will also influence your perception of an individual.
    First impression counts right? =)
    One who challenged other's perception is a prominent figure and in this case, i thought Mr Obama showed his worth to be the President of United States. Don't you agree?

    ReplyDelete
  4. HI RACHEL!

    I agree with you on your stand that Obama's comment was totally inappropriate! I have similar views, especially that Obama is a big public figure, his comment is influential! What if his comment, "jackass" influences many others to hate Kayne, many others who were probably neutral about this issue?

    Kayne who might have his reasons (although personally i am on Team Taylor). He does not deserve such a harsh comment from Obama. I am disappointed. I expected Obama to have better considered the potential impact of his comment.


    Comment on mine too!
    cforceleste.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Racheal

    It is largely debatable. President Obama could have easily turned away from such trivial matters but alas, what's said was said. I think you were very right to point out (though inexplicitly) that there are racial tentions in the US, thus it wasn't half that bad Obama criticised a fellow black man.

    And yes, regarding proximity, Kanye West was probably a very household name in the US, so president Obama probably intervened as he may have wanted society not to learn from him.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think the part where by you said 'Thank goodness though, that it was Obama, a black man, who aimed his insult at another black person.' I would certainly agree that if a white president had condemed on Kanye, there would certainly be issues raised on racism.

    Well I think that Obama, as president of one of the biggest nation, should not have used the word 'Jackass'(at least not infront of camera). Rise of curiousity among people might think that Obama likes critising people and the perception that people would give Obama might not be good.
    Even though i might feel that Kanye west should be called a 'jackass' i feel that Obama should not have said it on CAMERA(Obama has the right to say what he wants).

    Well overall, I think we should not judge Obama just by the word 'jackass'. Who are we to perceive what Obama is by just one word that he said? We don't know Obama enough to critiscise him.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello!

    I like the interesting observation that you take on regarding the comments made by a "black" American to another "black" American. True, sometimes people don't notice that much when a person of a similar ethnic group critize another but large emphasis is placed when a different group critize another of different ethnic.

    However, I feel that a leader is still a human being and all human beings make mistakes. So why should we focus on their mistakes and not on the good deeds that they have done for us? Maybe it's human nature to prick at other's faults so as to increase our confidence? Hmm...

    -Chu Yuan

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Rachel, Totally agree with you that in society, we all have shared social understandings, and embedded in us is a cognitive schemata, or mental framework. That is what makes us collectively the human race.

    There are things that we all do, no matter what social status we are…. We eat, breath and shit. Beyond that, what differentiates us is our behavior, both publicly and privately. In public, we get scrutinize while in private, it is the essence of who we are. I for one think the President should be who he is, both publicly and privately… and to stand tall, be always in good standing. If he falls a little, society should be more forgiving.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Rachel, personally, I see no wrong in President Obama calling Kanye West a 'jackass' because he was in the wrong the first place, or probably he was really drunk during the awards. Anyway, I feel the President Obama is just being straight forward and speaking how he feel. Yes, we may have certain type of perceptions of how a President should behave/speak. But then again, a president is still a human, and all of us make mistakes too, isn't it? Furthermore, I think President Obama meant no harm at all (:

    Breda

    ReplyDelete
  10. hi!

    I agree with you that we have the tendancy to form idealised representation of leaders and this can cause our opinion to be one sided.

    Personally, I think that both President Obama and Kanye West should be aware of the context they are in. In this case, in an interview, i think that it will not be very appropriate for President Obama to use the word. If he is conversing with his family and friends, i don't think that will invite so many criticisms.

    shiqi:)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I agree that we all have formed person prototypes of different kinds of people, and I must admit that I was shocked with Obama's crude comment about Kayne.
    I was not unhappy with the fact that Obama had opinions, but rather I was disappointed that Obama could actually forget the context he was in, and pass such comments without thinking through the possible consequences.
    We can also see how the media can very quickly dissiminate information out. From the clip Obama had asked for what he said to be cut out, but now it is on youtube and everyone knows about it. Secrets are definitely harder to keep with the media around.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi there.

    About Obama's criticism of Kayne - was our interest in this topic sparked really because of emotional proximity? Would we not still be interested in strangers' affairs for things they do we deem immoral? I feel that the emotional proximity factor you stated is not really valid, as anyone would be interested in some other president calling anyone else a jackass - as long as it is reported. The key factor is the media who plays up such events, and tells us what to be interested about.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Obama is cool! Defying the social prototype of a president, he insists on being honest, and it shows himself in a better light, for he is perceived to be understanding of the public's views. His behaviour and speech definitely has no relations with his capabilities as a president.

    West deserves it.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I agree with clouds. I don't think context matters this time around because Kayne was really behaving badly so criticisms of him are justified. As for those who are offended by what Obama said, its time to change the stereotypical view of president!

    ReplyDelete
  15. itsmorethanjustwords (JUNYING)>>
    Hey there! I absolutely agree that Obama was merely passing a casual remark. But everyone may not think this way, and since Obama is a public figure his image is extremely important and he cannot afford to offend even a minority group of people. Obama cannot assume that there are many people like us around who are lenient towards his comments, and instead assume the other polarity.

    ReplyDelete
  16. lyn (MARILYN)>>
    Hello! Yes Obama did look worried after he said the crude word. And fantastic point there about how Obama's comment should not be seen as vulgar but instead to recreate the racial harmony that Kayne almost destroyed. Of course, there must be other ways to do this instead of criticising Kayne so openly don't you think?

    ReplyDelete
  17. commtalks (LI NI)>>
    yes perception plays a huge role in our lives! Obama certainly tipped the perception balance of president here, but i do not think he showed his worth as President of the United States yet. In fact i thought that perhaps his lack of control over his word use showed that he was not used to formality of presidency. Nonetheless, we should still cut him some slack!

    ReplyDelete
  18. CELESTE>>
    Thanks for agreeing with me! Yes Obama certainly might influence other people to hate Kayne, he might even influence kids into thinking that calling other people 'jackasses' is completely fine! As for Kayne I really wonder how he feels about America's first black president calling him a jackass. It must have hurt. So negative consequences also include Obama verbally hurting someone personally, which is very unprofessional.

    ReplyDelete
  19. rocknstone (CHERVIN)>>
    Hi Hi! yes i think race is perhaps a form of non verbal communication as well. it means something more when a white man criticises a black man and but a black man criticising another black man holds an entirely different meaning altogether.

    ReplyDelete
  20. AMOS>>
    Hmmm valid point there that we should not judge Obama by one word he said. But then again we cannot stop the fact that people DO judge. That is the sad sad reality of things and we or rather Obama has to approach his speeches with this in mind. Otherwise i do agree with you that Obama has the freedom to voice his views, but there is still a code of conduct to adhere to. If everyone openly voices their views, this world would be a very colorful aka vulgar place.

    ReplyDelete
  21. handwritingsonthewall (CHU YUAN)>>
    Hey girl! yes we humans love to judge and pick at other's faults and flaws. But that is human nature is it not? In fact we even set higher standards for people in leadership positions which is why it is harder for them in terms of maintaining a good clean reputation. The fact of the matter is not how we should act, but how we act anyway that Obama has to take into consideration and communicate appropriately.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think that Obama's harsh comment on Kayne has some positive effects instead and teaches others some valuable lessons! Like Obama is actually telling us how grabbing the spotlight from someone is a jackass-y thing to do.

    ReplyDelete
  23. LIM>>
    We all wish that we can be who we are both privately and publicly. But does society really allow us to do that? If we fall is society really forgiving. Let alone if the president slips up, will society accomodate his mistakes despite their already high standards/expectations of him?

    ReplyDelete
  24. blacksticks (BREDA)>>
    Hey babe! Yes humans all make mistakes, and I agree that we should not be too harsh on Obama regarding his comments. But unfortunately not everyone things this way, and Obama has to consider that when he speaks, because he is a political figure after all and image is really important to him.

    ReplyDelete
  25. com101sq (SHIQI)>>
    YUP the whole reason why we have opinions of this particular happening is because we have certain held perceptions of how a president should behave!
    And while leaders like Obama should be aware of the context they are in, society should change their perceptions as well.

    ReplyDelete
  26. ANNA>>
    Hello. Yes it is rather disappointing that Obama acted so casually, but then again, from the clip one can see that the interview had actually not started and they were only having a casual conversation. So my guess is that while Obama should have paid more attention to his words, it was also untimely that the camera caught him while he was having an informal 'moment'.

    ReplyDelete
  27. clouds (YUJIE)>>
    Hey! great point on how Obama's critism of Kayne actually shows how he understands public views! So this episode might indeed be a plus point for him. But Obama was still aware of how people might negatively view his comment, even if they felt the same way, hence his request to cut that clip out.

    ReplyDelete
  28. JUN>>
    Hey there! But what if people do not want to change their stereotypic views on how a president should behave? We cannot change them, but Obama could have done was tailor his speech in such a way that it does not offend anyone.

    ReplyDelete
  29. MONDE>>
    Hello! While I agree with you that the media does play a huge role in garnering our interest in this topic, I still maintain my stand that emotional proximities play a part as well. There is a reason why reporters report more on particular people than others, simply because masses feel more attached to such particular groups of people. Hence our interest in this issue is also because we or rather Americans listen to Kayne's songs, they voted for Obama and listened to his speeches, so there is this sort of familiartiy or association with them, even if they have never met Kayne or Obama before. Thanks for the constructive comment! Really appreciate it.

    ReplyDelete
  30. XIAOZHEN>>
    Hey! I've never really thought about it from that angle before! I do hope more people can see it from this light! It is always better to be able to get something positive out of any situation.

    ReplyDelete
  31. hellos.

    I agree with you on the point that as media now effectively transmits information really fast. It could be that previous leaders had also acted in inappropriate ways but their acts were just not reported. Obama is leading in a time where media presence is very strong, and as such he should be careful not to let it backfire on him. I like the fact that Obama is already very IT savvy anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I feel that Obama totally killed his own image by saying those words. Although I understand that even political leaders are humans, they should control the words being used, especially when being interviewed. I don't think it was the right context when Obama spoke that way.

    Reminds me, I don't understand why Obama was presented with the Nobel prize. Totally uncomprehensible! I was discussing this with some of my friends who are also involved in grassroots together with me and we couldn't find an absolute explanation which supports him getting that recognition. Maybe that recognition would keep him away from starting another war. I don't know. Well, I do hope everything turns out well for Obama for his term!


    =)Kai Ting

    ReplyDelete